Josy P. Pullockara
josy at ctfd.cmmacs.ernet.in
Sat Oct 4 12:40:41 PDT 2003
On Sat, 2003-10-04 at 04:00, Michael J. Aftosmis wrote:
> I don't know if I agree with your assessment that actually doing the
> clipping and computing the volume is "overkill" in 3D.
Actually, I follow your work (VKI lectures and others) closely. It is a
pleasure to receive a reply from you. I agree that in practise it may
not be an overkill but I "felt" it "may" be in principle :)
> There are
> very effecient algorithms to do it. If you think of your AABB
> as a coordinate aligned clipping window you can use a
> sutherland-hodgeman algorithm to do it. We do this all the time in
> (http://www.nas.nasa.gov:~aftosmis/cart3d/). Even doing all the clipping
> in software, its not hard to code this so that you can generate 2-10
> clipped polyhedra per minute, getting all the volumes, volume
> centroids, face areas, and face centroids along the way.
Before embarking on the above method described by you in your
publications I wanted to make sure I was not missing other methods that
can just give me volume and area fractions as the two objects (box and
plane) involved are quite simple! (simple - relatively)
> If you're intent on an approximate method, there are some
> "volume-of-fluid" approaches from LLBL that may be of interest to
> you. Perhaps one of them will join the discussion.
Do you or others use exact sub-cell information in practise for
computing flows? Since, researchers like Colella, Berger, LeVeque and
others do not "seem" to use sub-cell information, I thought it was not
required to have sub-cell information. I thought it is a general
practise to approximate the intersection by a line/plane.
Thank you very much for your kind suggestions. I will go ahead and
implement the clipping algorithms. I hope some mathematician will not
come up with a proof "it is impossible to obtain the volume fractions
without computing the polytopes" :P
Josy P. Pullockara <josy at ctfd.cmmacs.ernet.in>
National Aerospace Laboratories, INDIA.
The compgeom mailing lists: see
or send mail to compgeom-request at research.bell-labs.com with the line:
Now archived at http://www.uiuc.edu/~sariel/CG/compgeom/maillist.html.
More information about the Compgeom-announce